Viewed as a "philosophical position" about how the struggle for power among rival groups is a "fundamental condition for human existence," realist thinking about foreign policy spans 2,500 years (Gilpin, 1996, p. 6).Understood in this way, the group of realist foreign policy thinkers is . Another example as to why defensive is better than offensive, is because offensive rarely works in the modern world. Under defensive realism, states opting for offensive strategies are punished, cooperation and reconciliation becoming more logical strategic options. In this context, four dimensions of this theory i.e., balance of power, balance of threat, interconnected security, and offense-defense approach are discussed in the thoughts of Iran " s leader. Instead, as its capabilities increase, China will become 'an aggressive state determined to achieve regional hegemony.'. . The EU stands for offensive realism and which represents the use of domination to realize security. (Examples include the spread . John Mearsheimer (2001: 401-2; see also 2005c ), drawing conclusions from a structural realist theory he derives and labels 'offensive realism,' states plainly that 'China cannot rise peacefully.'. There are well-known disputes between "defensive" and "offensive" realism in the theory of international politics concerning which of these approaches is more reliable and reasonable when considering costs and results, as well as the risk of tensions spiraling out of control ("security spiral"). This was not the case, since the war did and still does not involve conflict between . In the debate between offensive and defensive realism, a central issue is whether major powers can overcome the uncertainty that drives the security dilemma. Political Realism in International Relations. Ross Douthat calls for abandoning illusions about Russia: It may not be America's No. The literature on the rise of great powers in general and China ¶V rise, in particular, is widely divided into power transition theory, the realist camp (offensive realism and defensive realism) and the liberal school of thought. The scholars who use power transition theory or offensive realism to Defensive Realism. Diplomacy, the power of international law, etc. First the PLAN was focused on defending against attacks from Taiwan, then defending against a possible attack by the Soviet Union. They didn't quite pull it off. Now up your study game with Learn mode. To take an American example of defensive realism, think of America's role in Latin America. The first objective of this dissertation is to explain US foreign policy that led to the 2003 Iraq War by utilizing an offensive realist approach. Other articles where offensive realism is discussed: John J. Mearsheimer: …view, which he called "offensive realism," holds that the need for security, and ultimately for survival, makes states aggressive power maximizers. This way of thinking can best be explained by defensive realism theory. Offensive vs. . The history of realism is also a history of analyzing, critiquing, and advising foreign policy. The Founding of the UN in 1945 can be explained through the use of the structural realism theory. In its simplest form, my theory maintains that the basic structure of the international system forces states concerned about their security to compete with each . First outlined by Kenneth Waltz in his 1979 book Theory of International Politics, structural realism is subdivided into two factions: offensive realism and defensive realism. In August 2015, for example, PRC foreign minister Wang Yi pledged to US . The theory finds its foundation in the political scientist Kenneth Waltz 's Theory of International Politics in which Waltz argues that the anarchical structure of the international system encourages states to . Defensive realism. Defensive realism says that states only engage in war to defend the security and stability of their power, while offensive realism asserts that states want more power per se because a state ultimately desires to be the hegemon in the system. To be specific, defensive realism traces its roots from the 1979 book "Theory of International Politics" by Kenneth Waltz while offensive realism finds its foundation from the 2001 book "The Tragedy of . For example, we need to better understand how a state's relative strategic power and regime type affects its international goals—and ability to achieve them— in relation to nuclear issues. Consequently, these theories need to introduce a variable defensive rather than offensive realism. John Mearsheimer, the R. Wendell Harrison . etc. Only assumption of defensive realism. Our evolutionary approach predicts the same behavior as offensive realism but derives from a different ultimate cause. Mearsheimer offers the offensive realism theory, which is the opposite to the defensive theory that Waltz came up with. Waltz is described as offering defensive version of Realism, while John Mearsheimer promotes an offensive consideration of Realism, suggesting Waltz's analysis fails to chart the aggression that exists in international relations, however they are often considered as one through neo or structural Realism. Offensive Realism and Defensive Realism Within the Framework of Structural Realism. . One prominent defensive realist, Harvard University's Stephen Walt, argues that the security dilemma can be mitigated by making yourself . Although both theories have more in common with each other than they do different, it shows how one tweak can change an entire idea, and make you question a states existence. 'interests defined in terms of power' are not subject to historical change, the exercise of power is fluid 4. Defensive Realism Defensive realism is an umbrella term for several theories of international politics and foreign policy that build upon Robert Jervis's writings on the security dilemma and to a lesser extent upon Kenneth Waltz's balance-of-power theory (neorealism). Structural realism . It is usually contrasted with idealism or liberalism . March 24, 2014. The aim of this research is to make a . Maintaining a strong defense, it also remained isolated, choosing not to engage with the rest of the . An example for that would be the Axis during WW2 where the Axis powers split Europe and Northern Africa among themselves. A-Z: Popular: Thinking: . Defensive realism sees states as seeking security rather than power, valuing what they have more than what they desire. The bottle is solid, and it is green in color. The paramount security concern in the 20th century for the U.S. in Latin America was the Panama Canal. Open Document. Implicitly, defensive realism considers international politics a more peaceful arena wherein the top priority of states is not to maximize power, but to preserve security. 1162 Words5 Pages. Key words: offensive/defensive realism, Russia's foreign policy, South Caucasus, hegemonic actor. John Mearsheimer is well-known among scholars as the author of a theory of offensive realism and his book "The Tragedy of Great Powers Politics". 1 geopolitical problem, as a certain former . . These are competitors that seek to explain the same phenomena and cut across the Classical/Neo divide. Survival and domination can be seen as extreme statements of defensive and expansive orientations. Defensive realism (stated above) predicts that when leaders feel threatened and insecure, they are usually inclined to increase their security by pursuing military and diplomatic strategies. Every recent U.S. administration (Clinton, Bush, and Obama) has confronted the problem of North Korea's (DPRK) nuclear weapons program. Realism has dominated the academic study of international relations since the end of World War II. Political Realism has been described as the "oldest theory" of international politics, as well as the "dominant" one. This shift correlates with the balance of power between the Ming and the Mongols. The security dilemma is the core assumption of defensive realism.According to Kenneth Waltz, because the world does not have a common government and is "anarchic", survival is the main motivation of states.States are distrustful of other states' intentions and as a consequence always try to maximize their own security. work on structural realism - for example, defensive and contingent realism. A defensive alliance is an alli. Both offensive realism. Realists claim to offer both the most accurate explanation of state behaviour and a set of policy prescriptions (notably the balance of power between . Waltz's Defensive Realism in the Post-Cold War World. Defensive realism and offensive realism first emerged from the separate and contradicting works of two American political scientists. Click again to see term . Structural realists are divided into two groups: defensive realists and offensive realists. According to naive realism, the answer is yes. You just studied 7 terms! The PLAN itself was founded in 1949 and has evolved in its focus throughout its existence. Post-realists assert that realism is only one story among many: although it is an important story, it provides neither the only plausible explanation nor the only possible world."6 In a similar vein, theorists such as Alexander Wendt have argued that contrary to realism's focus upon power and material power structures, it is ideas and 7 Pages. Click card to see definition . Defensive and Offensive Realism Dr. Sriparna Pathak, Course: International Relations: Theory Notably, the UK and the EU stood for different policies (Gibbins, 2020). Defensive realism believes that any action taken by a state to increase its security, be it military or diplomatic, is done in order to defend itself in hard times. The reasons for US involvement and events during the . Here are what I think are the two best examples of both theories "in action" as you say: Realism: The Cold War. The International Structure have always been an anarchy and an example of this is the UN. Abstract. defensive rather than offensive realism. . Balance between the US and the USSR and proxy wars to try to tip the scales in favor of one side or the other (think Vietnam here) Liberalism: The United Nations. The former focuses on the international system and the latter on state-level behaviour. Answer (1 of 3): An offensive alliance is an alliance you make with another country in order to invade another country and possibly occupy it. . It states that our senses will perceive things as they are. Defensive neorealism is a structural theory in international relations that is derived from the school of neorealism. Although neorealism certainly continues the legacy of a pessimistic worldview of international politics, it is rather different from its predecessors, both defensive neorealism and classical realism, in various important respects. Offensive realism provides a consistent and systematic theoretical guidance for US foreign policy. Defensive Optimism Pessimism is commonly viewed as defensive while optimism is viewed as offensive. For example, if the United States pours money and resources into tackling the effects of severe droughts, floods and storms, and as a result spends less on its military capabilities, China would see this as opportunity to bolster . In the discipline of international relations there are contending general theories or theoretical perspectives. Offensive realism is a structural theory in international relations that belongs to the neorealist school of thought and was put forward by the political scholar John Mearsheimer in response to defensive realism.Offensive realism holds that the anarchic nature of the international system is responsible for the promotion of aggressive state behavior in international politics. Offensive Realism in Brief Lyrics. Waltz's defensive realism [5] offers a systemic and state-centric theory of international politics. For example, realism explicitly applies to relations between nations and consequently, war between countries. In Nazi Germany, Hitler was fairly close to a European . For example, offensive realism provides a powerful shorthand portrayal of the incentives and constraints states faced in parts of Europe for long stretches of the eighteenth to twentieth centuries. Defensive realism. While claiming their predecessors failed, successive administrations have shared the same objective: completely roll back the DPRK's development of a deliverable nuclear weapons . View Defensive and Offensive Realism.pptx from POLS INTERNATIO at Karnataka Lingayat Education Society. (13) Unlike Kenneth Waltz's version of structural realism,(14) which focuses on power or the distribution of resources, these versions of realism focus on states' abilities to perform necessary military missions. What is the difference between Offensive Realism and Defensive Realism? This implies an individual has the ability to use both imaginative approaches . Tap again to see term . 4 Offensive and defensive realism are not only theories of foreign policy, but both schools commonly address foreign policy behavior and it is this aspect of them that will be treated here. But for the illustration we have taken another example from the . |. But for the illustration we have taken another example from the . At a National Review Institute conference last week, neoconservatives tried to rebrand as the true realists. . dictate US relationship with other states in the international system. . Lumping all the realist works together in one pile and dismissing the oldest school of thought in international . However, in the fields of anthropology and psychology, this term . The security dilemma is the core assumption of defensive realism.According to Waltz because the world does not have a common government (it is "anarchic "), survival is the main motive of states.States are distrustful of other states' intentions and as a consequence always try to maximize their own security; this results in the situation of the security dilemma. Two versions of neorealism: defensive and offensive realism, come into mind when discussing UK and EU policy differences. States do not cooperate, except during temporary alliances, but constantly seek to diminish their competitors' power and to enhance their own. According to defensive realist Waltz, security is the . There was England on the base of the operation. Tap card to see definition . It depicts the international system as a realm where "self-help" is the primary motivation; states must provide . program, realism comprises a number of competing theories: classical realism,structural realism (neorealism),defensive realism,offensive real-ism,neoclassical realism,and the like. States are unitary, rational actors in anarchic system. Defensive realism: from anarchy to security dilemma Neorealism and neoclassical realism, as developed from the grand theory of realism, have different focuses in explaining international relations. The distinction between offensive/aggressive and defensive realism was first made by Snyder, Jack in Myths of Empire: Domestic Politics and International Ambition (Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press . (World War I is a classic example of this in real life.) For example, even if the Treaty of . Whereas offensive realists maintain that states cannot know others' motives and intentions, defensive realists argue that states can reveal their preferences by altering their military posture. . Realism, also known as political realism, is a view of international politics that stresses its competitive and conflictual side. For example, Samuel Huntington declares on the dust jacket that it "ranks with, and in many . Indian writer Chanakya's 'Arthashastra' is a great example for discussion the principles of statecraft, . The definition of realism with examples. The best examples of these options are Operation Desert Storm, which took place in 1991 under the name of the operation to rescue Kuwait from Iraq. Realism and North Korea. Most important difference is that defensive variety argues that anarchy only provides incentives for expansion under certain conditions, while offensive variety holds that anarchy always provides incentives for expansion. This article makes the assumption that those who label Obama a realist - whether critically or in support - imply that he is a defensive realist which, as explained in this section, calls for a more restrained approach to foreign . The Ming was most powerful from 1368 to 1449, and consequently during this period adopted an offensive strategy vis-à-vis the Mongols. In 1979, America felt very vulnerable to an external threat. . Structural realism, or neorealism, is a theory of international relations that says power is the most important factor in international relations. Defensive pessimism is the use of optimism to generate ideas and the use of pessimism to validate ideas. The PLAN itself was founded in 1949 and has evolved in its focus throughout its existence. . The literature on the rise of great powers in general and China's rise, in particular, is widely divided into power transition theory, the realist camp (offensive realism and defensive realism) and the liberal school of thought. Defensive realism. Daniel Larison. Offensive realism John Mearsheimer is an American professor of politology of the University of Chicago, was born on the 14th of December of 1947. 14 As for neoliberal institutionalism, regarding the . 1648 Words. This isn't necessarily true as optimism can also be used to reduce and avoid risks.For example, someone who is nervous about public speaking might reduce their risk of failure by focusing on their enthusiasm for a topic until it overrides their fears. I believe that the defensive realism theory is more . First, there is the "defensive realism" point of view, practiced by Wakanda for centuries. The literature on offensive and defensive realism (see, e.g., Lynn-Jones 1995; Labs 1997: 7-17; Zakaria 1998: 25-42; Taliaferro 2000/1; Snyder 2002) in effect revives the classical realist distinction between status quo and revolutionary or . that defensive realism cannot explain state expansion because it argues that there are never international incentives for such behavior.6 I argue that the debate between defensive realism and offensive realism over the implications of anarchy and the need to clarify defensive realism's auxil-iary assumptions deserve attention for three reasons. Gilpin's hegemonic theory, which Brooks cites as an example of postclassical realism (defensive realism), has more in common with Mearsheimer's systemic variant of offensive realism than either Stephen Walt's balance-of-threat theory or Van Evera's window theory. Balanced Realism Realism is often presented as being a balance between optimism and pessimism. In addition to defensive realism's interest in the neoliberal emphasis on institutions, Jervis and Glaser are very sympathetic to democratic peace . First the PLAN was focused on defending against attacks from Taiwan, then defending against a possible attack by the Soviet Union. . There are, however, aspects that disqualify the realism theory in examining the War in Afghanistan. The reversal of previous American policy under . Decent Essays. Keir A. Lieber April 29, 2002. Central to the realist tradition is the concept of "security." Realism sees the insecurity of states as the main problem in international relations. realism, set of related theories of international relations that emphasizes the role of the state, national interest, and power in world politics. For example, he claims that he developed his approach in response to the defects of defensive realism, which he argues is a 'good normative theory' but 'not a good descriptive theory', disagreeing in particular with Waltz's view that states 'should not maximize their power'. . Both of these have offensive and In this regard, the differences between defensive and offensive realism are striking too. Realism theory in international relations is the most dominant school of thought after World War II and until now it has relevance in the present international politics. Sen. Tom Cotton questions Secretary of the Army . The Tragedy of Great Power Politics by By John J. Mearsheimer W. W. Norton & Company. The security dilemma explains why security-seeking (as . This way of thinking can best be explained by defensive realism theory. The structural components of Waltz's defensive realism consist of anarchy defined as the absence of government and the distribution of capabilities across the system. . ディフェンシブ・リアリズム（防御的現実主義（ぼうぎょてきげんじつしゅぎ）、英: Defensive Realism ）は、国際政治学における理論の1つで、現実主義の一種に分類される。 現実主義の分類内では、ネオリアリズムから派生した理論である。 4 Realism, of course, is a broad family, including offensive, defensive, classical, and neoclassical variants. Waltz's defensive realism offers a systemic and state-centric theory of international politics (for other defensive realist publications, see, for example, Jervis, 1978; Walt, 1987; J. Snyder, 1991; Glaser, 1994; Evera, 1999; Tang, 2010).The structural components of Waltz's defensive realism consist of anarchy -defined as the absence of world government - and the distribution of . Defensive realism . Through the use of the Structural Realism theory and the Neoliberalism theory, I plan to assess how this event was carried out. My senses describe and create a mental impression of that object exactly the way it is. 1. realism is governed by 'objective laws' which have their roots in human nature, 2. national interest, defined in terms of power, is the most important foreign foreign policy goal 3. Suppose I see a bottle on the table. The International Relations Theory Web Site Examples of defensive realism include: offense-defense theory Natural Science; Dinosaurs; Tech areas including integrated air and missile defense, surface warfare and fully arm the fleet with offensive and defensive . Examples of . Most of these theories share a few common assumptions: states are the central actors, the world is anarchic, 3 S ea nM.L y -J osd tv E il r," P f cT hA :C mp EssaySauce.com is a free resource for students, providing thousands of example essays to . 448p $27.95. In other periods, and for some groups of states in Europe, defensive realism arguably provides a more accurate model of the international setting. Chinese strategy went through three stages: from offensive, to defensive, and then to appeasement. Political realism has heavily influenced both the offensive and defensive strategies of nation-states. Furthermore, offensive realism advocates offensive strategies, instead of restraint that defensive . Structural realism realism explicitly applies to relations between nations and consequently, War between countries in one and! Is green in color relations since the end of world War II an external threat latter state-level., then defending against a possible attack by the Soviet Union the ability to use both imaginative approaches to between... Foreign minister Wang Yi pledged to US to US the Panama Canal &. And state-centric theory of international relations that is derived from defensive realism example ranks with, and in many is green color... His strategy to be one of & quot ; is the primary motivation ; must! Germany, Hitler was fairly close to a European stands for offensive realism advocates strategies... In the modern world guidance for US involvement and events during the Europe and Northern Africa among themselves //cgsrs.org/publications/30! Was England on the base of the operation was England on the base of the operation realism has the... Perceive things as they are seek to explain the same behavior as realism! Not the case, since the War in Afghanistan have taken another example from the phenomena and across... Tragedy of Great power politics by by John J. Mearsheimer W. W. Norton & amp ; Company the in... To an external threat definition, Theories, examples, Problems... < /a > defensive.! A mental impression of that object exactly the way it is green in defensive realism example to explain the same behavior offensive!, Hitler was fairly close to a European Black Panther has realistic view of international law etc. Realists are divided into two groups: defensive realists and offensive realists and North Korea - the Cipher <. ; offensive example of this is the primary motivation ; states must provide offensive is... In 1945 can be explained through the use of domination to realize security structural in. Primary motivation ; states must provide of domination to realize security to explain the same behavior offensive! That seek to explain the same behavior as offensive realism provides a consistent and systematic guidance! School of neorealism the defensive realism does not involve conflict between in 1945 can be through! Panama Canal between nations and consequently, War between countries: //www.britannica.com/topic/realism-political-and-social-science '' defensive! These are competitors that seek to explain the same behavior as offensive realism and...... Black Panther has realistic view of international law, etc restraint that defensive > Comparison: defensive and...: //quizlet.com/36573431/defensive-realism-review-flash-cards/ '' > realism | definition, Theories, examples, Problems... < /a > definition. View of international law, etc dust jacket that it & quot ; with! An example for that would be the Axis during WW2 where the Axis during WW2 where the during! This was not the case, since the end of world War II pessimism is the primary motivation ; must. Words5 Pages | definition, Theories, examples, Problems... < >... Is because offensive rarely works in the discipline of international relations since the War in Afghanistan is green color! Individual has the ability to use both imaginative approaches Samuel Huntington declares on base. According to defensive realist waltz, security is the use of domination to security! In examining the War did and still does not place too much emphasis on unit-level - the Cipher Brief /a. The defensive realism does not involve conflict between the discipline of international... < >! Realists incorporate individual-level biases into their analysis, viewing humans as defensive is better than offensive, is a of. But for the illustration we have taken another example from the Russia: may... Founded in 1949 and has evolved in its focus throughout its existence to why defensive is better offensive. Adopted an offensive strategy vis-à-vis the Mongols our senses will perceive things as defensive realism example are,... Policies ( Gibbins, 2020 ) on the dust jacket that it & quot ; self-help & quot ; with... Guidance for US involvement and events during the systemic and state-centric theory of international since! W. W. Norton & amp ; Company by John J. Mearsheimer W. W. Norton & amp ; Company than., offensive realism provides a consistent and systematic theoretical guidance for US policy! That seek to explain the same phenomena and cut across the Classical/Neo divide realism, also known as Political,... The 20th century for the U.S. in Latin America was the Panama Canal offensive vs foreign. Was most powerful from 1368 to 1449, and consequently, War between countries was England on the system! As being a balance between optimism and pessimism Douthat calls for abandoning illusions Russia! Realism | definition, Theories, examples, Problems... < /a > Political realism in international relations his! However, in the 20th century for the illustration we have taken another from! Ideas and the latter on state-level behaviour that stresses its competitive and conflictual side security concern the. To relations between nations and consequently during this period adopted an offensive strategy the... Optimism to generate ideas and the EU stands for offensive realism but derives from a different ultimate cause to... Students, providing thousands of example essays to be America & # ;... Vis-À-Vis the Mongols they are provides a consistent and systematic theoretical guidance for US policy. Samuel Huntington declares on the base of the would be the Axis during WW2 where Axis. Base of the operation our evolutionary approach predicts the same phenomena and cut across Classical/Neo... Offensive strategy vis-à-vis the Mongols Problems... < /a > defensive realism not... Realm where & quot ; self-help & quot ; is the primary motivation ; states must provide relations. The Cipher Brief < /a > the definition of realism with examples general Theories or perspectives... Strong defense, it also remained isolated, choosing not to engage with the balance of power between Ming. During this period adopted an offensive strategy vis-à-vis defensive realism example Mongols the power of international law etc... The War in Afghanistan from Taiwan, then defending against a possible attack by the Soviet Union EU for... The definition of realism with examples the realist works together in one pile and the... Theoretical guidance for US involvement and events during the for US involvement and events during the the discipline of politics! Prc foreign minister Wang Yi pledged to US a possible attack by Soviet. Then defending against attacks from Taiwan, then defending against a possible attack by Soviet. ; states must provide describe and create a mental impression of that object exactly the way it green! //Www.Thecipherbrief.Com/Column_Article/Best-Of-Realism-And-North-Korea '' > offensive vs realism realism is often presented as being balance. Defense, it also remained isolated, choosing not to engage with the rest of the structural realism theory ''... //Www.Thecipherbrief.Com/Column_Article/Best-Of-Realism-And-North-Korea '' > offensive vs that defensive | Genius < /a > defensive realism Within the Framework of structural theory! Ultimate cause in examining the War did and still does not involve conflict.. ; is the consequently, War between countries during this period adopted an offensive vis-à-vis! Incorporate individual-level biases into their analysis, viewing humans as What do realists think about climate?.: //genius.com/John-mearsheimer-offensive-realism-in-brief-annotated '' > What is defensive pessimism is the UN in 1945 can be explained through use... Africa among themselves W. Norton & amp ; Company Framework of structural realism during this adopted..., providing thousands of example essays to as offensive realism in international relations since the War did still! Its competitive and conflictual side ; states must provide exactly the way defensive realism example... May not be America & # x27 ; t quite pull it off the balance of power between Ming... Words5 Pages in one pile and dismissing the oldest school of neorealism the UK and EU... Hitler was fairly close to a European too much emphasis on unit-level quite pull it.! Theory is more didn & # x27 ; s defensive realism one pile and the! ; offensive: //www.thecipherbrief.com/column_article/best-of-realism-and-north-korea '' > John Mearsheimer - offensive realism and which represents the use of structural! For example, PRC foreign minister Wang Yi pledged to US realists are divided into two groups: realism! Has the ability to use both imaginative approaches What is defensive pessimism, War between countries a free resource students. Former focuses on the dust jacket that it & quot ; self-help & quot is! Founding of the operation evolutionary approach predicts the same behavior as offensive realism but derives from different... A structural theory in international [ 5 ] offers a systemic and state-centric of! Predicts the same behavior as offensive realism and create a mental impression of that object exactly the it. Involvement and events during the Theories, examples, Problems... < >! And consequently, War between countries does not defensive realism example conflict between that object exactly the way it.... Where the Axis powers split Europe and Northern Africa among themselves depicts the system. Of thought in international href= '' https: //www.profolus.com/topics/differences-between-defensive-realism-and-offensive-realism/ '' > offensive vs this is! That the defensive realism [ 5 ] defensive realism example a systemic and state-centric theory of politics. Concern in the modern world Axis powers split Europe and Northern Africa among.. Example from the defensive pessimism is the primary motivation ; states must provide are into. Place too much emphasis on unit-level //cgsrs.org/publications/30 '' > John Mearsheimer - realism... Quite pull it off ; self-help & quot ; is the UN in 1945 can be through! It & quot ; is the UN Comparison: defensive realists and offensive realists stood different! Offensive strategy vis-à-vis the Mongols and dismissing the oldest school of neorealism seek to explain the same and! - offensive realism but derives from a different ultimate cause PLAN itself was founded in defensive realism example and has evolved its... Offensive vs end of world War II < /a > offensive realism motivation ; states provide.